Short answer

Short answer: After the first term, the cheapest VPN-only plan we checked is Private Internet Access PIA VPN on its 40-month plan, at $81.20 every 3 years, or $27.07 a year. Next come Private Internet Access PIA VPN on its 12-month plan, at $47.88 every 12 months, or $47.88 a year, CyberGhost VPN on its 28-month plan, at $61.32 every 12 months, or $61.32 a year and Mullvad VPN on its 12-month plan, at €60.00 every 12 months, or €60.00 a year. The highest yearly cost shown is NordVPN Basic on its 27-month plan, at $139.08 every 12 months, or $139.08 a year. Surfshark does not show a renewal price before you pay. Checked November 18, 2026 (CyberGhost: November 17; ExpressVPN: November 17; NordVPN: November 17; Private Internet Access: November 17; Proton VPN: November 17).

Price per year after renewal, VPN-only plans

One row per term of 6 months or more for each provider's VPN-only plan, sorted by what it costs per year after the first term, lowest first. Mullvad's euro price is sorted by the dollar amount its pricing page shows. A renewal price that is not shown goes last.

ProviderTermFirst-term totalThen renews atPer year after renewalPrices
Private Internet AccessPIA VPN40 monthsnot shown$81.20 every 3 years$27.07See pricesPricing page
Private Internet AccessPIA VPN12 months$47.88$47.88 every 12 months$47.88See pricesPricing page
CyberGhostCyberGhost VPN28 months$61.32$61.32 every 12 months$61.32See pricesPricing page
MullvadMullvad VPN12 months€60.00€60.00 every 12 months€60.00See pricesPricing page
Proton VPNVPN Plus12 months$35.88$83.88 every 12 months$83.88See pricesPricing page
Proton VPNVPN Plus24 months$83.76$83.88 every 12 months$83.88See pricesPricing page
CyberGhostCyberGhost VPN6 monthsnot shown$41.94 every 6 months$83.88See pricesPricing page
ExpressVPNBasic15 months$74.85$99.95 every 12 months$99.95See pricesPricing page
ExpressVPNBasic28 months$83.72$99.95 every 12 months$99.95See pricesPricing page
NordVPNBasic15 months$74.85$139.08 every 12 months$139.08See pricesPricing page
NordVPNBasic27 months$80.73$139.08 every 12 months$139.08See pricesPricing page
SurfsharkStarter15 months$44.85not shownnot shownSee pricesPricing page
SurfsharkStarter27 months$67.23not shownnot shownSee pricesPricing page

Checked November 18, 2026 (CyberGhost: November 17; ExpressVPN: November 17; NordVPN: November 17; Private Internet Access: November 17; Proton VPN: November 17). Sales tax may be added at checkout.

Total cost for your timeframe

Pick how long you will use a VPN and see the total cost: VPN cost calculator.

The cheapest first year is not the cheapest later

Most long plans are sold at an introductory price that only covers the first term. A low first-term price can hide a high renewal price. Proton VPN Plus costs $35.88 for its first year, less than the $47.88 for Private Internet Access's 1-year plan. But Proton VPN Plus then renews at $83.88 a year, while PIA renews at $47.88.

That is why the table is sorted by the yearly cost after renewal, not by the first-term price. For the terms sold at an introductory price, this is the first term against what you pay per year after it:

  • CyberGhost, 28 months: $61.32 for the first term, then $61.32 every 12 months ($61.32 a year).
  • Proton VPN, 12 months: $35.88 for the first term, then $83.88 every 12 months ($83.88 a year).
  • Proton VPN, 24 months: $83.76 for the first term, then $83.88 every 12 months ($83.88 a year).
  • ExpressVPN, 15 months: $74.85 for the first term, then $99.95 every 12 months ($99.95 a year).
  • ExpressVPN, 28 months: $83.72 for the first term, then $99.95 every 12 months ($99.95 a year).
  • NordVPN, 15 months: $74.85 for the first term, then $139.08 every 12 months ($139.08 a year).
  • NordVPN, 27 months: $80.73 for the first term, then $139.08 every 12 months ($139.08 a year).

Plans that keep the same price

Two of the terms in the table renew at the same price as the first term: Private Internet Access's 12-month plan at $47.88 and Mullvad's 12-month plan at €60.00.

Mullvad charges €5.00 a month whether you pay monthly or for a year. Its yearly plan costs €60.00 in the first year and renews at €60.00 a year. Private Internet Access's 1-year plan costs $47.88 and renews at $47.88 every 12 months. Its 40-month plan costs less than its 1-year plan per year after renewal, but the first-term total of that plan is not shown on the pricing page.

Surfshark does not show a renewal price

Surfshark and Surfshark are last in the table because the renewal price is not shown. Surfshark's Starter plan costs $18.95 for the first 1 months. Neither the pricing page nor the checkout shows what it renews at before you pay: the checkout only says the plan renews at "the then-applicable renewal price".

We have not found the renewal price, so we do not estimate it, and the table says "not shown". The first-term price on its own does not tell you what Surfshark costs per year after the first term.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the cheapest VPN in year one not the cheapest later?

Because the first term is often an introductory price. Proton VPN Plus costs $35.88 for its first year, less than PIA's $47.88, but renews at $83.88 a year, while PIA renews at $47.88.

Does any VPN keep the same price?

Two of the terms in the table renew at the same price as the first term: Private Internet Access's 12-month plan at $47.88 and Mullvad's 12-month plan at €60.00. Mullvad charges €5.00 a month whether you pay monthly or for a year.